May 25, 2008 , The New York Times
By LESLIE KAUFMAN
JILL BOLTE TAYLOR was a neuroscientist working at Harvard’s brain research center when she
experienced nirvana.
But she did it by having a stroke.
On Dec. 10, 1996, Dr. Taylor, then 37, woke up in her apartment near Boston with a piercing pain
behind her eye. A blood vessel in her brain had popped. Within minutes, her left lobe — the
source of ego, analysis, judgment and context — began to fail her. Oddly, it felt great.
The incessant chatter that normally filled her mind disappeared. Her everyday worries — about a
brother with schizophrenia and her high-powered job — untethered themselves from her and slid
away.
Her perceptions changed, too. She could see that the atoms and molecules making up her body
blended with the space around her; the whole world and the creatures in it were all part of the
same magnificent field of shimmering energy.
“My perception of physical boundaries was no longer limited to where my skin met air,” she has
written in her memoir, “My Stroke of Insight,” which was just published by Viking.
After experiencing intense pain, she said, her body disconnected from her mind. “I felt like a
genie liberated from its bottle,” she wrote in her book. “The energy of my spirit seemed to flow
like a great whale gliding through a sea of silent euphoria.”
While her spirit soared, her body struggled to live. She had a clot the size of a golf ball in her
head, and without the use of her left hemisphere she lost basic analytical functions like her ability
to speak, to understand numbers or letters, and even, at first, to recognize her mother. A friend
took her to the hospital. Surgery and eight years of recovery followed.
Her desire to teach others about nirvana, Dr. Taylor said, strongly motivated her to squeeze her
spirit back into her body and to get well.
This story is not typical of stroke victims. Left-brain injuries don’t necessarily lead to blissful
enlightenment; people sometimes sink into a helplessly moody state: their emotions run riot. Dr.
Taylor was also helped because her left hemisphere was not destroyed, and that probably explains
how she was able to recover fully.
Today, she says, she is a new person, one who “can step into the consciousness of my right
hemisphere” on command and be “one with all that is.”
To her it is not faith, but science. She brings a deep personal understanding to something she
long studied: that the two lobes of the brain have very different personalities. Generally, the left
brain gives us context, ego, time, logic. The right brain gives us creativity and empathy. For most
English-speakers, the left brain, which processes language, is dominant. Dr. Taylor’s insight is
that it doesn’t have to be so. Her message, that people can choose to live a more peaceful, spiritual life by sidestepping their left brain, has resonated widely.
In February, Dr. Taylor spoke at the Technology, Entertainment, Design conference (known as
TED), the annual forum for presenting innovative scientific ideas. The result was electric. After
her 18-minute address was posted as a video on TED’s Web site, she become a mini-celebrity.
More than two million viewers have watched her talk, and about 20,000 more a day continue to
do so. An interview with her was also posted on Oprah Winfrey’s Web site, and she was chosen as
one of Time magazine’s 100 most influential people in the world for 2008.
She also receives more than 100 e-mail messages a day from fans. Some are brain scientists, who
are fascinated that one of their own has had a stroke and can now come back and translate the
experience in terms they can use. Some are stroke victims or their caregivers who want to share
their stories and thank her for her openness.
But many reaching out are spiritual seekers, particularly Buddhists and meditation practitioners,
who say her experience confirms their belief that there is an attainable state of joy.
“People are so taken with it,” said Sharon Salzberg, a founder of the Insight Mediation Society in
Barre, Mass. “I keep getting that video in e-mail. I must have 100 copies.”
She is excited by Dr. Taylor’s speech because it uses the language of science to describe an
occurrence that is normally ethereal. Dr. Taylor shows the less mystically inclined, she said, that
this experience of deep contentment “is part of the capacity of the human mind.”
Since the stroke, Dr. Taylor has moved to Bloomington, Ind., an hour from where she was raised
in Terre Haute and where her mother, Gladys Gillman Taylor, who nursed her back to health, still
lives.
Originally, Dr. Taylor became a brain scientist — she has a Ph.D. in life sciences with a specialty
in neuroanatomy — because she has a mentally ill brother who suffers from delusions that he is in
direct contact with Jesus. And for her old research lab at Harvard, she continues to speak on
behalf of the mentally ill.
But otherwise, she has dialed back her once loaded work schedule. Her house is on a leafy cul-desac
minutes from Indiana University, which she attended as an undergraduate and where she now
teaches at the medical school.
Her foyer is painted a vibrant purple. She greets a stranger at the door with a warm hug. When
she talks, her pale blue eyes make extended contact.
Never married, she lives with her dog and two cats. She unselfconsciously calls her mother, 82,
her best friend.
She seems bemused but not at all put off by the hundreds who have reached out to her on a
spiritual level. Religious ecstatics who claim to see angels have asked her to appear on their radio
and television programs. She has declined these offers. Although her father is an Episcopal minister and she was raised in his church, she cannot be counted among the traditionally faithful. “Religion is a story that the
left brain tells the right brain,” she said.
Still, Dr. Taylor says, “nirvana exists right now.”
“There is no doubt that it is a beautiful state and that we can get there,” she said.
That belief has certainly sparked debate. On Web sites like evolvingbeings.com and in Eckhart
Tolle discussion groups, people debate whether she is truly enlightened or just physically
damaged and confused.
Even her own scientific brethren have wondered.
“When I saw her on the TED video, at first I thought, Oh my god, is she losing it,” said Dr.
Francine M. Benes, director of the Harvard Brain Tissue Resource Center, where Dr. Taylor once
worked.
Dr. Benes makes clear that she still thinks Dr. Taylor is an extraordinary and competent woman.
“It is just that the mystical side was not apparent when she was at Harvard,” Dr. Benes said.
Dr. Taylor makes no excuses or apologies, or even explanations. She says instead that she
continues to battle her left brain for the better. She gently offers tips on how it might be done.
“As the child of divorced parents and a mentally ill brother, I was angry,” she said. Now when she
feels anger rising, she trumps it with a thought of a person or activity that brings her pleasure. No
meditation necessary, she says, just the belief that the left brain can be tamed.
Her newfound connection to other living beings means that she is no longer interested in
performing experiments on live rat brains, which she did as a researcher.
She is committed to making time for passions — physical and visual — that she believes exercise
her right brain, including water-skiing, guitar playing and stained-glass making. A picture of one
of her intricate stained-glass pieces — of a brain — graces the cover of her book.
Karen Armstrong, a religious historian who has written several popular books including one on
the Buddha, says there are odd parallels between his story and Dr. Taylor’s.
“Like this lady, he was reluctant to return to this world,” she said. “He wanted to luxuriate in the
sense of enlightenment.”
But, she said, “the dynamic of the religious required that he go out into the world and share his
sense of compassion.”
And in the end, compassion is why Dr. Taylor says she wrote her memoir. She thinks there is
much to be mined from her experience on how brain-trauma patients might best recover and, in
fact, she hopes to open a center in Indiana to treat such patients based on those principles.
And then there is the question of world peace. No, Dr. Taylor doesn’t know how to attain that, but
she does think the right hemisphere could help. Or as she told the TED conference:
“I believe that the more time we spend choosing to run the deep inner peace circuitry of our right
hemispheres, the more peace we will project into the world, and the more peaceful our planet will
be.”
It almost seems like science.
Copyright 2008 The New York Times Company
~
I included this article because Julie Taylor's experience of the nirvana she experiences on the right side of the brain is what being in trance/hypnosis feels like.
I always recommend that anyone who "owns a brain" - should read this amazing book.
Nina